Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please consider supporting us by whitelisting our website.

Bungling criminal busted for two armed robberies at same servo after returning days later to buy pie

Bungling criminal busted for two armed robberies at same servo after returning days later to buy pie 2

A bungling criminal has been caught by returning to the scene of two crimes, just days after he committed the second. 

Alexander James Palmer, 20, twice robbed the same service station while armed with a knife.

Advertisement

But when he went back a third time to buy a meat pie and chocolate milk, he was recognised by attendant he’d robbed a few days earlier.

Palmer’s first crime was committed on April 15, 2021 when he walked up the Shell Coles Express in the northern Sydney suburb of Forestville at 4.32am.

Alexander James Palmer, 20, twice robbed the Shell Coles Express in the northern Sydney suburb of Forestville (pictured)

Alexander James Palmer, 20, twice robbed the Shell Coles Express in the northern Sydney suburb of Forestville (pictured)

Advertisement

The doors were closed, but the attendant, who was counting the takings, buzzed him in. 

The agreed facts presented to Sydney’s Downing Centre District Court said Palmer put a concrete block down to stop the doors from closing. 

The block was later found to have his DNA on it. 

Advertisement

As he walked towards the counter, Palmer was seen on CCTV to have a 10cm-long knife in one hand and a Coles plastic bag in the other. 

The attendant said Palmer, who was an ice addict at the time, seemed nervous as he said ‘put all the money in the bag’.   

Palmer then absconded with $397.50 in the Coles bag. 

Advertisement

Exactly one month later, a different worker was facing away from the counter when he heard a man say ‘hi mate’.

This time Palmer was armed with a 20cm-long kitchen knife, which he held on the counter, shocking the attendant.

Palmer left with $188.50 after telling the attendant to put all the money in a bag.

Advertisement

The court heard that when he returned home and began counting the money, he told a friend who was staying over that it was from his piggy bank.

Just days later, Palmer went back to the same servo, which was near to where he lived.  

Alexander James Palmer, 20, twice robbed the same service station while armed with a knife. Pictured is a police vehicle behind police crime scene tape

Alexander James Palmer, 20, twice robbed the same service station while armed with a knife. Pictured is a police vehicle behind police crime scene tape

Advertisement

The attendant on duty was the same person who was on during Palmer’s second robbery and recognised him.  

Palmer’s bank card was declined and he walked out to his car.

The worker took down his license plate number, called the police and Palmer was arrested soon after. 

Advertisement

Both Palmer and his mother gave evidence in court, revealing he was a mechanical apprentice who had become addicted to ice, the Daily Telegraph reported. 

At the time of the robberies, he owed his parents $6,000, was very thin, barely ate and constantly asked his family for more money.

Palmer was treated in an addiction centre for nine months, the court heard.

Advertisement
The police were called after a service station attendant recognised a customer as someone who had robbed him just days earlier. Pictured is a NSW police officer

The police were called after a service station attendant recognised a customer as someone who had robbed him just days earlier. Pictured is a NSW police officer

He was now in full-time work, close to finishing his apprenticeship and keeping away from drugs and alcohol, Judge Christopher Robison was told.

The judge said Palmer was a ‘model example of how one can change’.

Advertisement

‘Based on how he has turned his life around and how highly people speak of him, these two incidents were extremely out of character,’ he said.

‘He is extremely unlikely to reoffend.’

Palmer was convicted of two counts of armed robbery and sentenced to two years and nine months jail, to be served in an intensive corrections order – a sentence served in the community under the strict supervision of Community Corrections. 

Advertisement

He was ordered to continue his rehabilitation, abstain from illicit drugs and do 300 hours of community service.    

Advertisement

About The Author