Jon Stewart called SCOTUS the ‘Fox News of Justice’ and said the Justices should have been ‘honest’

Jon Stewart called SCOTUS the 'Fox News of Justice' and said the Justices should have been 'honest' 2
Advertisement

Comedian Jon Stewart branded the United States Supreme Court the ‘Fox News of Justice’ after it overturned Roe v. Wade. 

Advertisement

Stewart, 59, opened Thursday’s episode of The Problem with Jon Stewart, with an angry exclamation: ‘Guys, what the f**k!’ 

He asked three law professors – Leah Litman, Melissa Murray, and Kate Shaw – if they immediately went into ‘solution mode’ after hearing about the dramatic political and legal shift. 

Advertisement

Stewart then compared SCOTUS to the conservative new network – which has been accused by the left of being high partisan and spreading fake news. 

He said: ‘[This decision] makes the court a cynical pursuit. It feels like the Fox News of Justice.’

‘It is a cynical pursuit in the same way that Fox News would come out with ‘we’re fair and balanced’ under the patina of what would be a high-status pursuit to the betterment of society, journalism. They are a cynical political arm.’ 

Jon Stewart, 59, said the Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade was a 'cynical pursuit' and compared the Court to 'Fox News.' He said: 'It is a cynical pursuit in the same way that Fox News would come out with "we're fair and balanced"'

Jon Stewart, 59, said the Supreme Court’s decision to overturn Roe v. Wade was a ‘cynical pursuit’ and compared the Court to ‘Fox News.’ He said: ‘It is a cynical pursuit in the same way that Fox News would come out with ‘we’re fair and balanced”

Advertisement

Stewart said the decision was ‘political’ and has ‘nothing to do with scholarship or anything else.’ 

The comedian also criticized the Court’s conservative Justices, saying they should have made their opinions on abortion and Roe v. Wade very clear in their confirmation hearings. The Justices in question had made it fairly clear in their hearings they thought abortion rights were already a settled precedent. 

Democrats are now calling for an impeachment trial into the Justices, for allegedly lying under oath. 

Advertisement

Pro-choice Senators Susan Collins and Joe Manchin both said they felt misled by Justices Brett Kavanaugh and Neil Gorsuch in their confirmation hearing, as they were led to believe Roe v. Wade was set precedent. 

Litman said that – despite what they said under oath – ‘all of their prior work to date, it totally clear that they were going to do these insane, terrible things.’ 

‘It would have been one thing, if they sat in the confirmation hearings and said: ‘My entire ideological bearing is that life begins at conception and that abortion should be made illegal.’ And at the very least, you would respect their honesty and integrity,’ Stewart said. 

‘When you look at the ridiculous kabuki theater now of justice confirmation, where they can just go out there and just f**king lie, like if this were about debate, then they would’ve understood what perjury meant.’

Advertisement
The conservative Justices are under fire for the decision, and Stewart said they should have been 'honest' under oath. 'It would have been one thing, if they sat in the confirmation hearings and said: “My entire ideological bearing is that life begins at conception and that abortion should be made illegal.” And at the very least, you would respect their honesty and integrity,' Stewart said

The conservative Justices are under fire for the decision, and Stewart said they should have been ‘honest’ under oath. ‘It would have been one thing, if they sat in the confirmation hearings and said: ‘My entire ideological bearing is that life begins at conception and that abortion should be made illegal.’ And at the very least, you would respect their honesty and integrity,’ Stewart said

Shaw agreed that Justices were purposely placed on the court by Trump to reverse Roe v. Wade, but said they ‘didn’t say anything definite’ once at the hearings. 

‘But it wasn’t necessary [to say anything definite] because Trump knew and the Senators knew that they were,’ she said on the show. 

‘These three Justices were the product of a conservative legal movement who had been trained and groomed to adhere to and espouse a set of legal ‘theories’…[to] basically retrofit around a set of just conservative pet project outcomes.’ 

Advertisement

She also said stacking the court was an ‘exercise of raw power.’ 

‘They had the votes, so they did it,’ Shaw said on the show. 

Murray joked that this is the ‘one time that Donald Trump told the truth.’ 

Litman went on to say that this isn’t something that wasn’t expected, as the ‘Republican Party has spent decades putting people on the court to get the results that they want.’ 

Advertisement

Stewart went on to criticize the Court for stating they couldn’t regulate gun laws, but could regulate women’s bodies.

‘I mean, there is no consistency. States can’t regulate guns, but they can regulate [uteruses], you know?’ he said. 

He said the decision to overturn the decision was ‘philosophical’ rather than based on ‘reasoned debate.’ The host also said conservatives like to ‘cite the bible’ because it’s a bunch of ‘dead people’ who can’t ‘argue’ with. 

‘How is this not a religious decision? They are suggesting that life is beginning at conception with no evidence other than that’s what the creator said?’  

Advertisement

Many Americans slammed the court’s decision for combining church and state, and protests broke out across the nation. 

Prominent figures, such as Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Attorney General Merrick Garland slammed the decision, with the latter stating the decision was a ‘devastating blow to reproductive freedom in the United States.’

President Joe Biden, 79, said he would back killing the filibuster to pass federal abortion legislation and blasted SCOTUS’ ‘outrageous’ decision. 

Protests broke out across the nation after the decision was overturn (pictured: Arizona)

Protests broke out across the nation after the decision was overturn (pictured: Arizona)

Advertisement
Protesters in Washington Square Park in NYC after the protest. Democrats are now calling for some of the Justices to be impeached for what they say is lying under oath

Protesters in Washington Square Park in NYC after the protest. Democrats are now calling for some of the Justices to be impeached for what they say is lying under oath 

Speaking to reporters at the end of a NATO summit in Madrid, Spain, earlier this week, he condemned the ruling and its impact. 

America is better positioned to lead the world than we ever have been,’ he said.

‘But one thing that has been destabilizing is the outrageous behavior of the Supreme Court of United States in overruling not only Roe v. Wade, but essentially challenging the right to privacy.’

Advertisement

He also said he would support a carve-out so that Democrats in Congress could pass laws to protect abortion rights, even without 60 votes in the Senate.

‘The first and foremost thing we should do, is make it clear how outrageous this decision was and how much it impacts – not just on a woman’s right to choose, which is a critical, critical piece – but on privacy generally,’ Biden said.

‘And so I’m going to be talking to the governors as to what actions they think I should be taking as well.’

He added that the ‘most important thing’ was his belief that the protections granted in Roe v. Wade should be codified into law.

Advertisement

‘The way to do that is to make sure that Congress votes to do that,’ the president said.

‘And if the filibuster gets in the way, it’s like voting rights, it should be we provide an exception for this.’

Advertisement
Advertisement